How to Triage Vendor Pitches: A Fit / Hold / No Framework (Free Template)
Most of the time spent on vendor pitches isn't reading — it's deciding, again and again, with no fixed rules. Write the rules once and anyone on your team can triage the same way in seconds. Here is a three-bucket framework and a template you can copy.
Three buckets are enough
| Bucket | Meaning | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Fit | Relevant to a current priority or plan | Send to the owning team and reply |
| Hold | Possibly relevant, wrong timing or missing info | Keep in a list to revisit |
| No | Unrelated or a category you never buy | Log it, no action |
The “Hold” bucket matters. It keeps next quarter's options without forcing a decision today.
Build criteria from your side, not the pitch
Judging pitches by how polished they look leads to inconsistent calls. Start from your own situation instead:
- Current priorities — e.g. “cut time spent on invoice entry”.
- Plans and timing — e.g. “replace HR system by April”.
- Budget range — e.g. “under $500/month, no setup fee”.
- Categories you never buy — e.g. “job-board ads, SEO outsourcing, lead lists”.
- Must-know questions — e.g. “security certifications, minimum term”.
The “never buy” list does the most work: recurring pitch categories become one-second decisions.
Copy-paste template
VENDOR PITCH CRITERIA (updated: ____) Current priorities (likely FIT) - - Plans and timing - e.g. Time-tracking review — by April Budget - Monthly: up to $___ Setup fee: ___ Never buy (NO) - - Must know before saying FIT - Customers of similar size/industry - Pricing - Contract term Who decides - Hiring / training → HR - Software / security → IT - Office / facilities → Operations - Anything else → General inbox
Keeping it useful
- Review monthly. Priorities change; stale criteria send the wrong pitches through.
- Log hard calls. Patterns in “not sure” cases show what's missing from the list.
- Ask teams what they're looking for. The front desk can't know every team's needs — collect them.
Put the criteria into the system
A criteria doc only helps when someone reads it. If your intake checks each pitch against these rules automatically, people only look at the result. More on writing rules a system can use: turning business priorities into pitch criteria.
FAQ
How often should I revisit the Hold list?
Whenever a new project starts in that area, and otherwise about once a month.
Who should own the criteria?
Leadership owns company priorities; each team owns its own needs. The front desk or ops uses the combined list.
How detailed should the criteria be?
Two or three lines per section is enough to start. Add to it whenever a pitch is hard to call.
Summary
Use three buckets — Fit, Hold and No — and build criteria from your priorities, timing, budget, never-buy categories and must-know questions. Review monthly, and let your intake apply the rules so people only see the results.