7-Point Checklist to Evaluate a Cold Vendor Pitch in Under a Minute
Somewhere in the pile of cold pitches there's occasionally the exact tool you were about to go looking for. You don't need to read every email in full to find it. Seven quick checks are usually enough.
Start with one question: was this written for us?
A message where only the company name has been swapped in usually means the sender hasn't looked at your business. Those rarely fit. A message that references your product, industry or a recent announcement deserves a closer look.
The seven checks
1. Is the problem specific?
“Boost efficiency” says nothing. “Cut the time your finance team spends keying in supplier invoices” tells you exactly who and what.
2. Is there a link to your situation?
Does it show any research — your size, industry, hiring page, tech stack?
3. Is there a price range?
Without one you can't judge budget fit. Even “from $200/month” is enough to decide.
4. Are there comparable customers?
Named logos aren't always possible, but “used by 40 companies in logistics, 50–300 staff” is a useful signal.
5. Is the sender verifiable?
Real company, working website, named person, direct contact details. If not, don't engage.
6. Is the ask proportionate?
“Can I send a one-pager?” costs you nothing. “Book an hour with our VP” costs a lot. Light asks are easier to test.
7. Does it match a current priority?
The deciding check. A great product that doesn't match anything you're working on goes to Hold, not Fit. Keep your priorities written down (template here).
Printable checklist
| Check | Yes | No |
|---|---|---|
| Specific problem and audience | Read on | Hold or No |
| Shows research on us | Read on | Likely a template blast |
| Price range given | Can decide | Need to ask |
| Comparable customers | Can decide | Need to ask |
| Verifiable sender | OK to engage | Ignore |
| Light first ask | Easy to test | Decide on timing |
| Matches a current priority | Fit | Hold |
When information is missing
Asking every rep for pricing and references by email is slow. Better to collect them up front through your sales door, so the pitch you see is already complete. If you decide to engage, use one of these reply templates.
FAQ
What if the pitch has no pricing?
If it's otherwise relevant, ask for a one-pager. For the future, require a price range on your sales form.
A great product that we don't need now?
Put it on Hold and revisit when a related project starts.
How can I tell if a vendor is legitimate?
Check the company website, the sender's name and direct contact details. If you can't verify them, don't engage.
Summary
Check whether a pitch was written for you, then confirm a specific problem, research on your business, pricing, comparable customers, a verifiable sender, a light first ask and a match with current priorities. Collect missing details up front to avoid back-and-forth.